The Atlantic Thread Herring can be distinguished from the Blueback Herring, Atlantic Menhaden, American Shad, and Hickory Shad by the presence of an elongated trailing dorsal fin ray. The Gizzard Shad which also possesses a trailing dorsal ray can be distinguished from the Atlantic Thread Herring by its comparatively deeper body and a lack of black tips on its dorsal and caudal fins as with the Atlantic Thread Herring.